Understanding the Distinctions and Parallels Between Team Charters and Team Working Agreements in Software Development
While these two tools share common goals, they have distinct purposes and structures.
Team Charter
A team charter is a foundational document that outlines the overarching vision, mission, and strategic goals of a team. It sets a clear direction and defines the team’s purpose and core objectives.
Key characteristics include:
- Vision and Mission: The charter defines the team’s purpose and the high-level goals that align with the organization’s objectives.
- Scope and Boundaries: It clearly outlines the team’s responsibilities, deliverables, and boundaries.
- Roles and Responsibilities: Defines the roles of each team member and identifies key stakeholders.
- Success Metrics: Establishes the criteria for measuring the team’s progress and success.
- Resource Requirements: Highlights the resources (budget, personnel, tools) needed to achieve the team’s goals.
- Risk Management: Identifies potential risks and mitigation strategies.
Team Working Agreement
A team working agreement is an artifact that defines the norms, guidelines, and expectations for how team members interact and collaborate daily.
Key characteristics include:
- Behavioral Guidelines: Specifies the expected conduct and behavior among team members, such as respect, punctuality, and constructive feedback.
- Communication Protocols: Outlines how information is shared, including meeting structures, frequency, preferred communication channels, and response times.
- Decision-Making Process: Establishes how decisions are made within the team, including consensus-building strategies.
- Conflict Resolution: Defines approaches to resolving conflicts that may arise during collaboration.
- Work Process Standards: Sets norms for workflow management, coding standards, and review processes.
- Continuous Improvement: Encourages regular retrospectives to review and improve team practices.
Similarities Between Team Charters and Team Working Agreements
Despite the differences in focus and structure between Team Charters and Team Working Agreements, both share several similarities. The primary one is that they facilitate team alignment by ensuring that all members are working toward shared objectives, establish clear expectations around behavior and communication, and provide a framework for resolving conflicts.
Facilitate Team Alignment
Both aim to ensure that all team members are aligned with the team’s goals and working effectively toward shared objectives.
Establish Expectations
They both set expectations around team behavior, communication, and collaboration.
Support Conflict Resolution
Each provides a framework for resolving conflicts by clarifying roles, responsibilities, and interaction norms.
Promote Transparency
They foster an environment of openness by providing a clear understanding of team goals, expectations, and operational standards.
Evolve Over Time
Both are dynamic and should be revisited and updated periodically to reflect changing team needs and organizational goals.
Differences Between Team Charters and Team Working Agreements
In software development, team charters and working agreements are integral tools for building effective teams, each with distinct purposes and structures. The team charter focuses on strategic aspects such as defining the team’s mission, goals, and overall direction. In contrast, the team working agreement zeroes in on operational norms and daily collaboration guidelines. While the team charter is broader in scope and covers roles, responsibilities, and resource requirements, the team working agreement is narrower, concentrating on behavior, communication, and workflow standards.
Moreover, team charters are more formal and comprehensive, often requiring higher management approval, while team working agreements are collaboratively created and less formal. Understanding these differences allows teams to employ both effectively to meet strategic and operational needs.
Differences Between Team Charters and Team Working Agreements:
Focus and Purpose
- Team Charter: Focuses on the strategic aspects, such as defining the team’s mission, goals, and overall direction.
- Team Working Agreement: Concentrates on the operational aspects, setting norms and expectations for daily collaboration.
Scope
- Team Charter: Covers a broader scope, including roles, responsibilities, resource requirements, and risk management.
- Team Working Agreement: Narrower in scope, focusing on team norms and interaction protocols.
Structure and Format
- Team Charter: More formal and comprehensive, often requiring approval from higher management.
- Team Working Agreement: Less formal and collaboratively developed by the team members.
Audience
- Team Charter: Intended for a wider audience, including stakeholders outside the team.
- Team Working Agreement: Primarily designed for internal team use.
Creation and Ownership
- Team Charter: Typically created by team leads or managers with input from team members.
- Team Working Agreement: Created collectively by the entire team, with shared ownership.
Despite their differences, as outlined above, team charters and team working agreements share several important similarities. Both tools align team members toward shared objectives, establish clear expectations, and provide a framework for resolving conflicts, promoting transparency and continuous improvement.
By using both in tandem, software development teams can achieve strategic direction and operational efficiency, fostering a cohesive and productive working environment.
Conclusion
In summary, a team charter and a team working agreement serve complementary purposes in software development. While the team charter establishes the strategic foundation, the team working agreement provides a practical framework for day-to-day collaboration.
By understanding their similarities and differences, software development teams can leverage both tools to create a cohesive, productive, and harmonious working environment.
Building a Foundation for Trust: The Team Working Agreement
While nothing can guarantee project success… there are things a team can do to improve your chances.
A Team Working Agreement can clarify how the team plans to work together, helping them gel more quickly and build trust and confidence in one another. In Scrum teams, it’s critical for the Scrum Master to make sure this gets created as soon as possible.In this article we cover what it is, why you should have one, what it looks like, and what to do once created.
Unlock the Power of Team Working Agreements: Join Our Exclusive “Team Working Agreement” Luncheon for IT Leaders
45-Minute “Team Working Agreement” Presentation and lunch.
Are you starting a new team or looking to help a team improve its outcomes? Join us for lunch and a workshop exploring how leaders can create and use team working agreements to transform team dynamics and structure collaboration. This workshop covers the essentials of building agreements that enhance communication, productivity, and continuous improvement.